Tag Archives: MN NOC

Navell Gordon is a Man. Media, #Pointergate & Dehumanization

9 Nov

In case you missed it, Navell Gordon and Anthony Newby of Minnesota Neighborhoods Organization for Change (NOC) were on Melissa Harris Perry’s show on MSNBC Sunday morning.  Gordon is the young man in the now famous photo with Minneapolis Mayor Betsy Hodges, the one at the heart of the now national #pointergate story. Watch:

Navell Gordon has face. He has a name. A Voice. A Story.

Thank you, Melissa Harris Perry for introducing the country to the young man whose name, voice and story was blurred and distorted by an irresponsible journalist and the television station backing him.

One of the most frustrating aspects of KSTP’s #pointergate debacle is that the station’s “explanation” for why they ran with the insane accusation that Gordon and Mayor Hodges were flashing gang signs is as bad, as hurtful, as wrong, as the original story itself. In their Friday afternoon statement about #pointergate and their subsequent news followup  to the story, KSTP makes the point that their story was about the “Mayor’s judgment” and not Gordon, telling us that this is why they “blurred the individual’s face and did not name the group he was working for.“ As I wrote in a previous post,

That is not only not a good explanation, that is precisely the problem, KSTP. You ignored the context in order to sell a sensationalist story spoon-fed to you by the Police Federation.  If you had named the organization, explained what they were doing, and given the full context, viewers would have immediately seen how insane was the proposition that the Mayor and Gordon were flashing gang signs.

If you had explained the context, you wold have had to explain that NOC is an organization dedicated to improving the lives of young people of color, including and especially those who have made past mistakes.  If you had named Navell Gordon, you would have had to admit that sensationalizing his story by calling him a “convicted felon” isn’t news — his past, and a desire to rebuild it, is precisely why he’s doing the organizing work he’s doing.[…]

Your newsroom didn’t blur Gordon’s face and fail to name NOC out of some concern for him or the community — you did that because, had you done basic journalism, your story would have fallen apart.

Someone on Twitter later pointed out something I’d missed when I first saw the story. The KSTP newsroom didn’t just blur out Gordon’s face, they blurred out his t-shirt so you can’t read what it says: “VOTE”.Navell Vote

KSTP was so intent on making it look like the Mayor was consorting with a bad, bad man that they erased his name, his identity, and any evidence that he was actually doing something very positive for himself and his community at the very moment that photo was taken.

KSTP still has lots to answer for. They say in that first segment that the person in question, Gordon, has no known gang ties. (If he’ not in a gang, aren’t those just fingers, KSTP?) That evening, however, in an epic twitter meltdown, reporter Jay Kolls called Gordon a “gangbanger.”  While his twitter feed has gone silent, Kolls’ daughter has also called Gordon a gang member in her public twitter feed.  I know that in Kolls’ initial inquiries into the story he unequivocally described the man in the photo as a “known” gang member.  So why, then, did the story air saying that he is not known to have any gang affiliations?  Did the information Kolls was fed by his sources turn out to be so far off base that it could not be corroborated?  If so, why did they run with the story anyway?

Some have speculated that KSTP’s double-down may have to do with bracing for a lawsuit.  If they and their reporter knowingly put out false information about an individual, one can see how admitting a mistake now could be tantamount to admitting slander.

The 1968 Memphis Sanitation Strike MLK stood with the day before he was assassinated.

The 1968 Memphis Sanitation Strike MLK stood with the day before he was assassinated.

KSTP now tries to hide behind their blurring of Gordon’s identify as if to suggest they were doing him some kind of favor when, in fact, it was ignoring him as a human being that allowed them to inflame racist fears of a dangerous black man who (even though their own research suggested otherwise) must be in a gang. By making him no one, he became the Black Everyman who is used to stoke fear.  As a blurred face, Gordon is Willie Horton and every other image ever used to scare white folks about crime.

KSTP simply could not tell the story they wanted to tell, of a white Mayor consorting with danger, if they had actually named Navell Gordon and treated him like a human being  and not an abstract concept.  Because Navell Gordon is not an abstract concept.  He is a man. A man who has made mistakes and admitted to that. A man who was, at that very moment they sensationalized, working to make his community better. Navell Gordon is a man who deserved to be treated like one.

And that is why KSTP must retract their story and apologize.

***

In my previous post, I listed a few actions people can take to express their outrage at KSTP.  Since I wrote that, NOC has started a public petition at pointergate.org.  If you’ve not yet signed it, go there now.

This Brown Guy Quits KSTP. You Can Do Something, Too.

8 Nov

In light of KSTP’s doubling down on their absurd report slandering a community group, a young organizer, and Mayor Hodges of Minneapolis– a report for which they have been ridiculed by local and national media and called “extremely racist” by the Southern Poverty Law Center–concerned Minnesotans have to kick up their game.  Until the station apologizes for their offensive news coverage and engages deeply with the community they have insulted, we should all do everything in our power to reject KSTP.

Here is the little I can do. For the past few years, I have had the opportunity to be an occasional political commentator on local TV and radio.  I love doing it.  I have been for the past several years part of the stable of commentators rotated on KSTP’s Sunday morning political talk show, “At Issue with Tom Hauser.” I have deep respect for Tom Hauser, he has always been very welcoming me to his show, and he is not a part of the news team that brought us #pointergate. That notwithstanding, after the station has chosen to blame the public for “missing the point” –get it? isn’t that cute?–I simply cannot in good conscience have anything more to do with KSTP.

Look, I’m not fooling myself. I’m not that big of a deal.  When I let “At Issue” know yesterday that I no longer felt comfortable or welcome on their station, the show’s producer was quick to respond: “We agree that it’s the best move for all of us.” (I may not be a big deal, but at least I know they read my tweets!)

I've been a regular guest of the "Face Off" segment "At Issue."

I’ve been a regular guest of the “Face Off” segment “At Issue.”

This is not a sacrifice for me. I don’t get paid to do any political punditry and I don’t do it that much.  (I was scheduled to be on At Issue twice this month.) Here is the only thing that truly bothers me about this.  If you watch At Issue regularly, you may have noticed one thing.  This light-skinned Puerto Rican is diversity on that show. And not just on that show.  Politics and political commentary, as well as news reporting, is simply not as diverse as Minnesota has become.

The thing I have wondered incessantly since Jay Kolls’ inflammatory piece first aired is, how many eyes looked at that story and saw no red flags?  Or, as one twitter use replied to me, “how many saw the red flags, but didn’t feel able to voice their concern?” I don’t know how many people of color are in the KSTP newsroom.  Anecdotally, after years of going into the studio fairly regularly, my guess is not a lot.

And so it is no small deal for me to make the KSTP news operation even less diverse, but there are times when we all have to do what little we can.  Some may be wondering, what can we all do together? Just as social media has brought national attention and derision to this travesty of journalism, we can use our collective power to let KSTP know that the public rejects their newsroom’s double-down.

What we can all do

First, let KSTP know of your outrage.  You can find their comment page here or you can call their newsroom phone at 612-588-6397. As always, please be civil but firm.

Also, continue tweeting at them your outrage, letting them know you refuse to watch their show and will  not patronize their advertisers.  Tell them to stop standing by the shoddy reporting of Jay Kolls.  He is damaging their brand, and maybe eventually they will realize the problem he is for them.

A twitter user calling her/himself @kstpadwatcher has begun tweeting the names of companies advertising on KSTP news.  The account was just created and doesn’t have many followers, but watch there to see if this develops into a full-fledged campaign.  With advertisers, let them know why you object to their sponsorship of a TV station that displays such an appalling disregard for journalistic ethics.

Let’s not let the Minneapolis Police Federation off the hook.  The Federation’s president, John Delmonico, chose to pursue a vendetta against Mayor Hodges because she dared assert that, while the overwhelming number of cops are good men and women doing their jobs, there are a few who damage the reputation of the whole force.  In response to Hodges’ “Open Letter” to the community of Minneapolis, Delmonico wrote his own open letter stating that the problem in the Minneapolis Police Department is too many officers are being disciplined. After his role in #pointergate, it is clear that John Delmonico himself is one of those cops damaging the reputation of the corps.  The Federation’s email address is info@mpdfederation.com and their phone number is 612.788.8444. Remember again, civil but firm. The twitter handle for the police department is @MPD_PIO. It is important to make a distinction between the action of Delmonico and the force as a whole.  It is the opinion of many that there is a cultural problem within the department; one role the public can play in improving that culture is highlighting the difference between cops who are building community and those who are damaging it.

(Let me point out that taking on the Police Federation and pushing for reform in the MPD is something that white allies can in particular play a big role in.  People of color, especially African-American men, have reason to be concerned that speaking out could lead to police harassment. One of the things that has been missed in a lot of the reporting on #pointergate –and that KSTP, of course, completely ignored–is that the young organizer in that photo with Mayor Hodges, Navell Gordon, had recently caused some bad press for the police department when he was featured in news stories alleging police harassment of Get-Out-The-Vote canvassers on the North Side. A question Jay Kolls didn’t think to ask the cops who spoon-fed him the pointergate story is, did this very recent bad press have anything to do with why cops were trolling his Facebook page photos to begin with?)

Finally, you can do something proactive.  Minnesota Neighborhoods Organizing for Change is the community organization that was slandered by KSTP and Jay Kolls.  They are a youth and people of color-led organization that is doing amazing work focused on the North Side of Minneapolis.  Support their work.  Throw a few bucks their way. You can also follow their work on Facebook.

About that KSTP “explanation” and Who is Missing the Point

I don’t at this point need to summarize for anyone the scandal of ethics and journalism that has become “Pointergate.” If you want to get caught up, some of the best things to read or listen to include the interview MPR News did with Anthony Newby, the Executive Director of Neighborhoods Organizing for Change; University of St. Thomas Law Professor Nekima Levy-Pounds’ brilliant, “Dear White People: Mayor Hodges is Not in a Gang”; and the first blogger to bring national attention to #pointergate, Shaun King, “Pointergate may be the most racist news story of 2014”.

Here I’d like to just speak a little to KSTP’s follow-up story, where they double down on their original reporting, re-interview the same retired cop and continue to ignore the outraged community (the only person of color featured in any of their news stories about pointergate is the blurred face of organizer Navell Gordon.

In their Friday afternoon statement about #pointergate and their subsequent news followup story, KSTP makes the point that their story was about the “Mayor’s judgment” and not Navell Gordon, telling us that this is why they “blurred the individual’s face and did not name the group he was working for.

That is not only not a good explanation, that is precisely the problem, KSTP. You ignored the context in order to sell a sensationalist story spoon-fed to you by the Police Federation.  If you had named the organization, explained what they were doing, and given the full context, viewers would have immediately seen how insane was the proposition that the Mayor and Gordon were flashing gang signs.

If you had explained the context, you wold have had to explain that NOC is an organization dedicated to improving the lives of young people of color, including and especially those who have made past mistakes.  If you had named Navell Gordon, you would have had to admit that sensationalizing his story by calling him a “convicted felon” isn’t news — his past, and a desire to rebuild it, is precisely why he’s doing the organizing work he’s doing.  How do we know?  He says it in this video,which also happens to capture the exact moment the pointergate photo was taken:

If you’d named the organization, you would have had to admit that, despite what reporter Kolls claimed in his first story, NOC did reach out to your newsroom to correct your interpretation before the first story aired.  I know this for a fact.  I have worked with NOC for years and have been in regular communication with Anthony Newby since Kolls first started digging around about this story.  I know, for example, that upon learning from KSTP what they planned to say about that photograph, NOC sent the newsroom many more photos of the event, including those showing Police Chief Janee Harteau right by Mayor Hodges when she canvassed with Gordon (and just out of frame of the camera of the #pointergate photo). Your newsroom didn’t blur Gordon’s face and fail to name NOC out of some concern for him or the community — you did that because, had you done basic journalism, your story would have fallen apart.

And the mendacity continues.  Friday night’s rehashed argument on KSTP still makes no mention of the above video, which debunks the story’s entire premise.  As of Friday afternoon Jay Kolls said on Joe Soucheray’s radio show “Garage Logic,” that he still had not seen the above video! (By the way, when Joe Soucheray and Twin Cities progressives are agreeing that your story was horse manure, you’ve got a problem).

Poor Jay Kolls must have been so busy sending angry tweets the night his story first aired (he has since stopped tweeting) he just didn’t have time to click on a video that has now been viewed over 160,000 times. He obviously still wasn’t able to get to it before the Friday night newscast.  Research is hard.

#Pointergate is about more than KSTP

Yes, we should focus a lot of organizing attention on a station as irresponsible as KSTP, but there are deeper issues that the community conversation must consider.  The next time talking heads on TV wonder why the relationship between police departments and the communities they serve, remember John Delmonico’s role in this and remember #pointergate. The next time journalists of color call out the lack of diversity in newsrooms and the effect that has on coverage, remember #pointergate. The next time a black kid gets shot because someone thought something he was doing with his hands — a gesture, reaching in his pocket, putting his hands up in the air — gets misinterpreted, remember #pointergate.